Compare Toilet Papers Compare Products Compare select up to 5 products to compare Score Product Price 80 Charmin Ultra Strong MegaBest Overall Toilet Paper $37 75 Charmin Ultra Soft MegaBest for Comfort $39 73 Quilted Northern Ultra Soft and Strong $43 69 Charmin Ultra GentleCare $55 68 Amazon Brand Presto Toilet PaperBest Bang for Your Buck $29 68 Quilted Northern Ultra Plush $24 67 Cottonelle Ultra Clean $26 66 Cottonelle Ultra Comfort $26 60 Angel Soft DoubleBest for Older Plumbing/Septic Systems $26 54 Charmin Essentials Soft $28 52 Seventh Generation 100% Recycled $32 51 Amazon Basics Toilet Paper $27 34 Scott Bath Tissue $41